Hurricane Helene: Click here to learn how South Carolina Legal Services can help with your disaster related legal needs.
South Carolina Legal Services > News > Uncategorized > The True Costs of “No-Payment” Home Equity Cash Deals and The Big Payment at The End

The True Costs of “No-Payment” Home Equity Cash Deals and The Big Payment at The End

By SCLS Consumer Fraud Unit

Many homeowners have built up a lot of value, or equity, in their homes. Some companies now advertise a way to get cash from that equity without taking out a loan or making monthly payments. These offers are often called home equity investments, shared appreciation agreements, or home equity sharing contracts.

Despite the names, courts are increasingly finding that these deals work like high-cost mortgage loans—and can put homeowners at serious risk.

How These Deals Really Work

Here’s an example:

A homeowner needs cash and signs an agreement to receive $50,000 today. In return, the company claims 30% to 70% of the home’s future value. There are no monthly payments, which sounds helpful.

But 10 years later, when the homeowner sells or refinances the home, the company may demand $200,000 or more, depending on how much the home has gone up in value. If the homeowner cannot pay, the company can force a sale of your home.

Even though these companies say they “share the risk,” the homeowner pays all property taxes, insurance, repairs, and selling costs, and still must pay off their regular mortgage first. The company’s money comes off the top.

The Fine Print Is Overwhelming

These agreements usually come with 100 pages or more of paperwork. Even experienced lawyers find them difficult to understand. For most homeowners, it is nearly impossible to spot the true cost or long-term risk.

Important details are often buried in fine print or spread across multiple documents. The lien recorded on the home usually does not explain how much the homeowner may eventually owe.

What Courts Are Saying

Courts across the country are now looking past the labels and focusing on what these products actually do. Judges are finding that these so-called “investments” often act like predatory mortgage loans and must follow consumer protection laws like the federal Truth in Lending Act.

Courts have also raised concerns about misleading marketing, including claims that the deals are “not loans,” involve “no interest,” or create “no debt.”

Key Takeaways for Homeowners:

  • There is no free money tied to your home.
  • “No monthly payments” does not mean low cost.
  • You may end up owing far more than you received.
  • These deals can block refinancing or force a sale.
  • The paperwork is long, complex, and hard to understand.
  • Courts are increasingly treating these as loans, not investments.

Before You Sign Anything:

Your home is likely your most valuable asset. If someone offers you cash tied to your home’s future value, get legal advice first. A trusted attorney can help you understand the real cost before it’s too late.

Ask questions before you sign:

  • Is this really “not a loan”? Maybe not. Courts are increasingly saying these deals function like loans, even if the paperwork says otherwise.
  • Can I refinance or sell later? Often not easily. These agreements can block refinancing or require a large payout before you can sell.
  • What happens if my home value goes up? The company may take a large share of that increase—sometimes far more than the cash you received.
  • What happens if I can’t pay at the end? The company may force a sale of your home.
  • Why is the paperwork so long? Complex contracts can hide costs and risks. If it’s hard for a lawyer to understand, it’s a red flag.
  • Who should I talk to first? A legal aid office, housing counselor, or trusted attorney—before you sign anything!